Check Availability

Best Restaurants on Lake Ontario

If you're looking for a place to eat on your way back from a fishing trip, you have a ton of options to choose from! Newfane, Olcott, and Wilson all have great dining establishments with a lot of character and great food. However, it can be hard to know which ones are worth your hard-earned cash!

We'll review the great restaurants in the area, and include a basic menu so you can get an idea of what each place serves. Hopefully, you'll find something that will quench your hunger nearby.

Newfane, NY

Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant
2885 Main St, Newfane, NY
Pizza isn't the only dish Cafora's is cooking. This Italian restaurant offers a host of sandwiches, burgers and chicken sandwiches. Cafora's is a community staple, opening its doors in 1970. The restaurant serves lunch and dinner.
Bill's Diner
2762 Main St, Newfane, NY
Bill's Diner is a great place to gather if you're in the mood for a good breakfast, lunch or dinner. The breakfast menu features omelets, pancakes and French toast, among others. The rest of the day you can find sandwiches, seafood and tasty desserts.
2875 Main St, Newfane, NY
Scruples offers a simple menu amidst a welcoming environment. Wings, chicken tenders and tacos are just some of the options you can have to eat. Thursdays are a great time to visit as wings are $1 each. The bar also offers cornhole and other great activities. 
Wilson's Pizza
2730 Main St, Newfane, NY
As with any homemade pizza restaurant, you have a ton of different flavors to choose from. This is a perfect restaurant to visit for groups with children. If you don't like pizza there are sandwiches and wings for you to enjoy instead.
Calhoon's Pub
2598 Main St, Newfane, NY 
Calhoon's Pub is a great place to unwind and eat with somebody that you love. One of the most popular restaurants around, at Calhoon's you'll have a chance to eat a great meal in our cozy corner of the world.
The Brookside Restaurant
2990 Lockport Olcott Rd, Newfane, NY
The Brookside carries an eclectic bunch of foods that are absolutely delicious. Mac and Cheese Bites, Poutine, Stuffed Banana Peppers...if you want to try something different from the norm, come here!
Food King
2764 Main St, Newfane, NY
This adorable Chinese restaurant is in the heart of Newfane. It's a popular restaurant with great food and positive reviews. You should give it a try if you're hankering for Orange Chicken.
Gordy Harpers
3333 Lockport Olcott Rd, Newfane, NY
This sweet restaurant is right across the street from Lake Ontario Motel and Inn! This makes it the perfect place for at least one of your meals on your vacation.
Mark's Pizza
6181 McKee St, Newfane, NY
Need to grab a pizza on the run to Olcott? There is no more convenient place than Mark's! You can choose from a variety of toppings and sizes so everyone in your party will have smiles on their face.

Olcott, NY

Covey's Cove
5855 E Main St, Olcott, NY
Another American restaurant that mixes the nation's favorite culinary masterpieces–burgers, fries, and mac and cheese! This restaurant is on the coast in Olcott, so it could be worth a visit if just for that reason.
Maxwell Station Restaurant
1571 Lockport St, Olcott, NY
Do you love a great fish dish? You'll find Haddock, perch, and other land-based foods when you arrive here!
Live Edge Brewing Company
2100 Coomer Rd, Burt, NY
Resting on the outskirts of Olcott, you'll find a quaint brewing company on the countryside. While they do offer tasty sandwiches and desserts, the focus is the beer.
Captain's Galley
5885 E Main St, Olcott, NY
The Captains Galley is a great place to go for a mid-day meal. They offer sandwiches, burgers, and other scrumptious delicacies throughout the day.
Valentine's on the Lake
5959 E Main St, Olcott, NY
Valentine's has one of the most consistently flawless menus around. While you can try American classics like herbed baked chicken and pork chops, you also need to try their homemade pierogis! They're amazing!

Lockport, NY

The Hilltop Restaurant
4206 Lake Ave, Lockport, NY
This charming pub offers a menagerie of foodie favorites. Buy some buffalo wings, spring for some fresh fish, or buy one of their luxury items like the prime rib.
3958 Lockport Olcott Rd, Lockport, NY
Looking for authentic Mexcian cuisine? Everything at Manitos Taco Shop will throw you south of the American border. It's spicy, flavorful, and definitely worth a visit.
Fred's Pizza
3998 Lockport Olcott Rd, Lockport, NY
You'll find Fred's Pizza quietly sitting in an outdoor mall. The pizza is worth the drive. They have a traditional and a sweet sauce that their guests love. Hopefully, you will too.

Wilson, NY

Wilson Boat House
57 Harbor St, Wilson, NY
If you like live music and parties, then the Wilson House is the place for you! With excellent food inspired from Lake Ontario, to top-tier drinks that will leave you bopping your head to the song, you'll discover that Wilson is the place to party.
Sunset Bar and Grill
3 Oconnell Island, Wilson, NY
Yet another restaurant that focuses primarily on seafood, and offers a premier view of the waterfront from your restaurant seat. It's an excellent choice nobody should underestimate!